Open Letter To Prof Alison Richard

The report carrying her clarification on Rahul Gandhi's MPhil raises more questions than answers

Dear Prof Alison Richard,

I am a Delhi-based journalist investigating the academic credentials of Rahul Gandhi, the Indian National Congress candidate contesting from the constituency of Amethi, Uttar Pradesh, for the Lok Sabha elections 2009.

I would like to get a detailed confirmation of your interview with Press Trust of India, the report of which was carried by The Times of India, IBN and Zee News. Recently, they (a newspaper and two television news channels respectively) carried an identical story (the web pages of IBN and Zee News do not give PTI the credit) in their respective websites, saying you, in the capacity of the Vice Chancellor of the University of Cambridge, have confirmed that Rahul Gandhi (son of former/late Prime Minister of India Rajiv Gandhi) received the postgraduate degree of MPhil on Development Studies from your esteemed university.

The three web pages are:
Your response seems to have been solicited in response to a critical report, questioning Rahul Gandhi's academic credentials, that had appeared in another newspaper:

The New Indian Express

The problem is that in the report that carries your word, there are no categorical (affirmative or negative) assertions to the following effect:
  1. Are Rahul Gandhi and Raul Vinci two names of the same person? Did Rahul Gandhi or his parents request your university to register him as a student under a pseudonym so that his high profile does not inconvenience him?
  2. Who is this Raul Vinci whose certificate has been displayed by the 'expressbuzz' website?
  3. Which department or section of your university issues MPhil certificates: the Examination Syndicate or the Committee of the department of the particular studies concerned?
  4. Why does your website say Rahul Gandhi gained his MPhil in "Development Economics", which also happens to be the entry in the affidavit that Rahul Gandhi filed along with the nomination papers of the Indian National Congress, which he is representing in the constituency of Amethi, Uttar Pradesh, for the 2009 general elections? Isn't the exact name of the course supposed to be Development Studies? Isn't Development Economics merely a module under the course, Development Studies?
  5. Why does your website name Rahul Gandhi under the column of prime ministers though he isn't, and never was, one? Was the reference to Rajiv Gandhi's son required in a strict, official record? Is it not akin to an unwarranted advertisement of your institution's high profile clients under an inappropriate slot? If not, are the names of the sons/daughters/kin of other alumni too put under slots where they do not belong? Is the family of Jawaharlal Nehru-Rajiv Gandhi-Rahul Gandhi the only one, more than one member of which were students of your university?
  6. Finally, if the 'expressbuzz' report is misleading and/or false, are you contemplating legal action against the print-cum-web-based publication?
Please send across your answers to put to rest a big controversy surrounding the affair in India.

Thanking you,
Regards,
Yours sincerely,
Surajit Dasgupta.
Mobile: 9910279861
21 Ras Vihar, 99 Indraprastha Extension, Delhi 110 092

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Fight Information With Information

Image
From the issue of cloning to publication of research in journals to intelligence tests carried out on various peoples to reproductive health, a brigade of 'conscience keepers' springs up to protest something it does not understand fully Cloning is now a hot topic of discussion in the fora of medical ethics. Prof Ian Wilmut of Edinburgh University, who gained celebrity status and attracted criticism equally for cloning the first mammal from an adult cell in 1996, has decided not to pursue a licence to clone human embryoes which he was awarded two years ago in favour of a method pioneered by Prof Shinya Yamanaka at Kyoto University, Japan, who has managed to create stem cells from fragments of skin in mice without using embryos. A UN report called last week for efforts to ban reproductive cloning worldwide after a US research team reported the first-ever cloning of a rhesus monkey whose embryo was cloned from adult cells and then grown to generate stem cells. 'Moralists' ...
Read more

Can't Let Go

Image
Hurriyat-Lashkar-Jaish-Harkat's Kashmir would be Taliban's Afghanistan II World beware! Masood Azhar's rally in Bahawalpur, Pakistan, where he had vowed to recruit half a million terrorists. He managed to recruit many more _______________ Surajit Dasgupta _______________ T here is no need for any Indian to get worked up for what national self-flagellation champion Arundhati Roy said yesterday — that Kashmir needs ' AzAdI ' from India as much as India needs ' AzAdI ' from Kashmir. Instead, as senior journalist Harinder Baweja reminded Times Now in the debate in response to Roy's statement, let us think of Vir Sanghvi and any other known opinion maker who is less of a maverick than Roy. Sanghvi is one of the two writers who, in their respective columns in the same newspaper — Hindustan Times — had suggested last week that the Indian union set the Kashmir valley free for it to fend for itself. The presumption made in course of their arguments by Vir San...
Read more

Khaas Aadmi Party

Image
The AAP's bluff of representing the ordinary citizen must be called. In time. A rvind Kejriwal and other prominent faces of the Jan Lokpal (JLP) movement that caught the imagination of the nation in 2011 did the right thing in July-August 2012 by deciding to launch a political party of their own. First, under the present system, whatever laws a group of activists thinks the people of the country need can be made only by getting into the legislature. Second, the mistake of the Jayaprakash Narayan-led movement of the 1970s could not be repeated; those who led the movement should not have passed on the baton to older politicians. Political observers, however, began raising some valid questions right after the announcement of the intention. How could a band of people, howsoever well-meaning, who had a single-point agenda of getting rid of corruption by instituting an all-powerful lokpal (ombudsman), and who were apparently ignorant of other facets of governance, run a party that ...
Read more